Family Feuds·
THE SECRET FEEDING
A new mother secretly uses formula at night after her husband forbids it, wrestling with guilt, secrecy, and a stormy fault line over who feeds their baby.
Keep supplementing or tell him first?
Be one of the first to vote.
At 3 months old, a baby was being fed formula in secret, hidden from the child's own father, who had called it "poisonous junk food."
The poster, a 22-year-old mother, had agreed before birth to exclusively breastfeed with her 38-year-old husband. They believed breast milk would be best for their daughter, and at first that was the plan. But breastfeeding did not come easily. The poster had an inverted nipple shape, and the baby was born with a tongue tie and lip tie, making latching hard from the start.
She began pumping right away and described herself as a "just enougher," producing almost exactly what the baby needed. After about a month of trying to get the baby to latch, and after spending money on lactation consultants and feeding specialists, she stopped trying to nurse directly and switched to exclusively pumping instead.
Her husband did not love that change. He argued that latching was better because saliva transfer could help with antibodies. Still, he accepted the switch because the baby was getting breast milk either way.
But the routine quickly became punishing. Pumping every two to three hours, including through the night, left the poster exhausted, and the milk she produced barely kept up with the baby's intake. About two weeks ago, she finally asked her husband if she could stop the night pumps and begin combo feeding, using formula to supplement.
He said no.
According to the poster, he refused to feed their child formula at all, claiming it contained toxins like arsenic and other bad ingredients or fillers. He called it "poisonous junk food" for babies. The poster was upset, because she was the one doing the pumping and losing sleep, and she believed supplementing should be her decision, especially since it was her "body making milk."
Her husband pushed back with a different argument: "as a father, he should have equal say on what our baby is fed."
After that conversation, the poster broke down. Then she bought formula anyway.
Now she has been using it during night feeds while hiding it from her husband. The baby is being fed, the pumps are finally easing up, and the formula has gone into the household without his knowledge.
But the secrecy has left her feeling guilty. She believes she is right to supplement, but she also knows she is lying to her husband. The question hanging over the whole situation is simple: was she wrong to feed their baby formula behind his back?