Family Feuds·
THE SECRET BIOLOGICAL CHILD
A couple who adopted a brood hides the fact that their youngest child is biologically theirs, sparking heated family debates about loyalty, truth, and protecting adopted siblings.
Should the secret stay hidden, or come out now?
Be one of the first to vote.
The secret was already out inside the house: their youngest son was biologically theirs. The question was whether the poster was an asshole for still keeping that from everyone else.
At 48, the poster says he and his wife, 46, came from a culture where arranged marriages are common. They were matched when he was 18 and she was 20. They both wanted children, but her medical condition made getting pregnant very difficult. Because the marriage was arranged, he says they never felt especially driven to keep trying over and over.
Instead, once they were older and financially stable, they built their family through adoption. Their first son came home at age 3, and he is now 26. A year later, they adopted a newborn daughter, who is now 22.
Then, about three years after that, the unexpected happened.
After a drunken hookup with his wife, she got pregnant.
That pregnancy became their youngest son, now 19. And when it happened, the couple made a decision that still defines the story: they told their families they had adopted another baby.
They did not tell the truth about the pregnancy. Only a few friends and select relatives knew. Their children all knew. Everyone else was left with the adoption story.
The poster says the reason was simple. For years, the family had pressured them to try fertility treatments and have a child that would "truly" belong to them. He and his wife worried that if the families learned their youngest was biological, the adopted children could be treated differently, like the "real" grandchild was the one born later.
That tension surfaced again in a talk with his 69-year-old father and a 47-year-old cousin. Both already knew about the pregnancy. The father admitted he had been disappointed that the poster never gave him a proper grandchild, and said he had held out hope until last year, when the wife turned 45.
The poster pushed back: he already had three grandchildren through him.
His father's response was blunt. It "wasn't the same."
Later, the cousin told him privately that keeping the secret from the father might be a bit of an asshole move now, since the children are grown and the father is old enough that he can't really treat them differently anymore.
The poster disagrees. "I don't think I'm an asshole but I'm curious what Reddit thinks," he wrote.
He also added one more note: "ETA: Me and my wife are not Indian, so please stop with all the racist messages and comments about Indian culture."