Family Feuds·
SCHOOL BOUNDARY BATTLE
Two households clash as a custody dispute redefines where children should study, pitting maternal boundaries against blended-family dynamics and the kids' own fears about leaving friends.
Should she keep saying no to homeschooling?
Be one of the first to vote.
A custody fight over two kids turned into a battle over who gets to decide whether they ever leave public school.
The poster, a 31-year-old woman, shares a 9-year-old son and 8-year-old daughter with her ex-husband, Aaron, 35. Their marriage ended after Aaron cheated. He later moved in with Nicole, 34, who already had four children of her own. Aaron and Nicole now also have a 2-year-old together, and they're expecting another baby.
The flashpoint was homeschooling. Nicole has homeschooled her own children since before she ever met Aaron. The poster said that issue came up before Aaron and Nicole married, but she didn't fight it then. Her children, meanwhile, go to public school.
Now Nicole says that arrangement is causing trouble inside her own house. She says it is unfair that her children see the poster's kids going to school while they do not. According to the poster, she answered bluntly: "I told her this was not my problem and she needed to figure out how to manage that." She added, "As that is the life of blended families. Not everything will be the same or equal for the kids from different marriages."
Aaron then started pressing for homeschooling too. He asked multiple times for the poster to homeschool the children, and at one point he even asked the children directly. They told their mother they did not want to leave their friends and teachers or stay home all day like Nicole's kids. The poster said that settled it: "I would not entertain the idea." She told the children, "I would not be saying yes to homeschooling for them."
But the requests kept coming. Nicole and Aaron began pushing for Nicole to homeschool the poster's children alongside her own. Their argument was that it would be fair, since their 2-year-old has started some form of pre-K homeschooling. The poster refused again. "I said no," she wrote, and had her lawyer send their lawyer a letter laying out her position. "My lawyer has also documented everything," she said.
The couple tried to take it further. They asked their lawyer to go back to court and get a judge to overrule her. Their lawyer told them "this would not go in their favor." Aaron later repeated that to the poster, giving her another thing to document.
Now Nicole and Aaron say the poster has no good reason to refuse except to disrupt their home, keep Nicole from having a bigger role in the children's lives, and block sibling bonding between Nicole's children and the poster's children. The poster says she has "many reasons to say no," and the biggest one is simple: the kids do not want to leave school.
"They are worried that I'll send them to school in September as planned," she wrote. "Which will happen."