Neighbor Wars·
THE NOISE COUNTERATTACK
On a tense apartment floor, a loud-kid dispute escalates as one resident sets up cameras, triggering management, police visits, and looming legal consequences.
Send the letter or move out?
Be one of the first to vote.
The downstairs neighbor didn't just complain back, she allegedly tried to get the poster arrested.
Three weeks earlier, a new apartment neighbor moved in below the poster and brought a 3- to 4-year-old kid who "loves to scream." After hearing it again and again, the poster started recording the noise and took the footage to management. Management spoke to the downstairs neighbor, who said she would "work on it."
The very next day, the downstairs neighbor fired back with her own complaint: the poster supposedly walked too loudly, even though the poster lived on the top floor.
Then the downstairs neighbor disappeared for nine days with the child. The poster figured they might have broken the lease. Instead of waiting around, the poster installed two Nest cameras inside the apartment, cameras that record audio and video 24/7 and keep cloud storage for 10 days.
When the neighbor returned on Monday, May 19, the tone changed fast. The poster says the downstairs neighbor began pounding on the floor from below at all hours, and the cameras kept catching it. One later clip was captioned: "Yes today is 05/22/2025 at 3:02 PM, as you can clearly hear my neighbors downstairs are banging in retaliation to a noise complaint I submitted about them.."
By Sunday, May 25, around 10:30 p.m., the pounding was still going. The poster called the non-emergency police line, waited about 45 minutes, and let officers in. The neighbor refused to answer the door. The poster got an incident number and planned to pick up the paper copy on Tuesday.
Instead, police showed up at the poster's door on Monday, May 26.
The call, according to the poster, came from the downstairs neighbor. She allegedly told dispatch that the poster was intoxicated, had threatened her from the patio, that she was a single mom with a kid, and that they had a relationship together.
The officers told the poster, "we're hear on a call regarding your interactions with the female downstairs." The poster answered with video. The footage showed what they had actually been doing at the time. When police asked to come in, the poster says, "No, this is about today, she called dispatch about you 5 minutes ago, can we please come in?" Five minutes later, they left.
On Tuesday, May 27, the poster got copies of both police incidents and the neighbor's full name. Then they retained a friend who is a county prosecutor and lawyer to start a cease and desist letter.
Management still hadn't stepped in. After the poster brought documentation, written notes, and videos, management responded by wanting a meeting instead. The poster posted, "b-bu can we just all have a meeting about this? I'm sure we can work it out!" and later: "sure, I'll bring my lawyer. We're just gonna have to ask her why she falsely informed police that I threatened her so we can pursue legal action against her. That shouldn't be a problem right?"
Now the poster says they're barely sleeping, fear another false report, and have shared the evidence with a lawyer, family, and an ex. They plan to send the cease and desist by certified mail, pursue symbolic damages in small claims court, and work with police on a false informing charge. If the neighbor doesn't move by the end of next week, the poster says they may move instead.