Family Feuds·
THE FAMILY SECRET
An adoptive family wrestles with finally unveiling the hidden origins of their 17-year-old daughter as her 18th birthday approaches, weighing fragile truths against her evolving sense of self.
Tell her now or wait for 18?
Be one of the first to vote.
A 17-year-old girl was heading toward college, and her adoptive parent was sitting on a secret they had promised to keep until her 18th birthday.
The daughter had been placed in their home as a foster child when she was just a few days old. The adoption was finalized soon after. For years, the story she knew was simple: she had been left at the hospital, and that was all. She never pressed for more. Her parents kept telling her the same thing: they would explain the rest later, after she turned 18.
Now that birthday was close. And the silence around her beginnings was getting harder to hold.
The daughter, the poster said, was happy, healthy, well adjusted, doing well in school, and "college bound!" On the surface, everything looked steady. But the full story had never been told.
"So here is the ugly truth, none of which she knows," the poster wrote.
Her birth mother was a crack addict who prostituted herself to get drugs. She was in her 40s when she had the daughter, after multiple other children who had all been placed in foster care and adopted. The birth father was unknown, even to the birth mother, because there were multiple possibilities.
The daughter was born cocaine exposed and with syphilis. She spent time in the NICU on antibiotics and was in the 25th percentile for size. When the adoption went through, the poster and adoptive family changed her name.
The poster also learned something else in a Google search: the birth mother had died about four years ago.
With the 18th birthday approaching, the poster worried the truth was too much, too soon. They said they had always meant to tell her more when she was older, but now it seemed different.
"It seems this would wreck her identity and self esteem, as well as bring a lot of sadness," the poster wrote. "What should I do?"
The update came after reading the replies. "Thanks everyone for the advice, both kind and harsh," the poster wrote. "It has been eye-opening and humbling to read your responses."
With help from the adoptive father, the plan shifted. The poster said they would move ahead "with carefully revealing all of the truth to our daughter as soon as practical," starting with the fact that her birth mother had died, and that she had other relatives in the area.